Novorossiya, Ukraine Civil War, Ukraine Politics

Kiev Advisor Horbulin: Five Scenarios for Ukraine War

by Kennedy Applebaum
Quemado Institute
June 22, 2015

Vladimir Horbulin (

Vladimir Horbulin (–


Vladimir Horbulin, the head of Ukraine’s Strategic Studies Institute, former secretary of the National Security and Defense Council of Ukraine, and advisor to Kiev regime leader Petro Poroshenko, has offered five scenarios for possible outcomes for the Ukraine-Novorossiya war. I present Horbulin’s scenarios first, then the comments of Fort Russ translator J. Hawk, and lastly my own optimistic predictions.




Donbass Conflict May Be Frozen

Translated from Polish by J. Hawk
Fort Russ
June 22, 2015

Poroshenko’s Senior Advisor: “The Donbass conflict may be frozen”

Vladimir Horbulin, an advisor to Poroshenko, believes that although freezing the Donbass conflict is undesirable and without future prospects, it may be that Ukraine will have to agree to such an outcome, as in the case of Transnistria. The head of the presidential Strategic Studies Institute and the former secretary of the National Security and Defense Council laid out five possible eastern Ukraine conflict resolution scenarios.

The first is that in the event of a large scale Russian invasion, Ukraine might prevail using guerrilla warfare. Horbulin believes that in this case Russia would be struck by very drastic Western sanctions, and moreover it is has limited financial and technological capabilities, plus its political system lacks resilience. Horbulin also notes that it would be the most heroic and casualty-demanding scenario for Ukraine, but also the least likely one.

The second scenario presupposes Ukraine gives up the Donbass and breaks off all relations with that occupied territory.

The third scenario calls for finding a separatist peace with Russia on terms favorable to it, in other words, recognizing Donbass autonomy, giving up Crimea, and ignoring the interests of Kiev’s western partners. In Horbulin’s view, this scenario would partially deprive the Ukrainian state of its independent foreign policy and tie Ukraine’s future to that of Russia. “This scenario is historically suicidal and politically senseless”, believes Poroshenko’s advisor.

The fourth scenario entails freezing the conflict along the lines of Transnistria, Abkhazia, and South Ossetia, which favors Russia. Although this variant makes it possible to immediately end the fighting on the Donbass, it is unfavorable to Ukraine because in the long term it will be an unattractive state in a state of permanent crisis, suffering from illegal humanitarian aid trade, arms and drug trafficking on a massive scale, and the presence of thousands of UN peacekeepers on the line of demarcation. Although that scenario is undesirable and does not offer a path to the final resolution, Ukraine might be forced to accept it under the pressure of internal and external circumstances. What’s more, nobody knows how long that state might last and what it would ultimately lead to.

The fifth variant presupposes a state of limited war and continuous negotiations in order to achieve the best results with lowest losses, although that path, in Horbulin’s view, demands a great deal of time, skill, and patience.

J. Hawk of Fort Russ comments:

I think it’s relatively obvious the first scenario is not going to happen, no matter how much the Strelkovs and Colonel_Cassads (or, for that matter, Horbulins) of this world want to see it. Simply because the end objective, Horbulin’s scenario number 3, will drop into Russia’s lap due to the “pressure of internal and external circumstances.” Without excessive bloodshed and plunging Russia into another Cold War, not to mention causing major changes to Russia’s political system (which is Strelkov’s ultimate objective).

Horbulin is clearly a die-hard, given his view on the “historically suicidal” third scenario. However, given that he’s already giving up on scenario 5 in favor of scenario 4 (however reluctantly), means that the distance to scenario 3 has grown that much shorter.

Kennedy Applebaum of Quemado Institute comments:

Scenario I: In the event of a large scale Russian invasion, Ukraine might prevail using guerrilla warfare. Horbulin disingenuously touts this variant as an obligatory tribute to Western disinformation policy. Russia will not invade Ukraine. And even it did, it would likely not fight on the side of Novorossiya. Indeed, I can’t imagine Putin’s army joining the campaign of the Novorossiya Armed Forces (NAF) in their quest for independence for the Donetsk and Lugansk Oblasts. Based on Putin’s traitorous neglect of the Donetsk and Lugansk Republics in the past, I fear Russian forces would speedily neutralize the NAF, quashing their advance under the guise of peace while forcing reunion with Ukraine. I stress this to caution Donbass supporters who pine for Russian intervention, an eventuality likely to backfire. The Donetsk and Lugansk People’s Republics must expect to fend for themselves. About Ukraine’s “guerrilla warfare” capabilities, having failed utterly against two tiny nations, there is little chance they would beat the world’s most efficacious military.

Scenario II: (To be dealt with last)

Scenario III: Recognizing Donbass autonomy, giving up Crimea, and ignoring the interests of Kiev’s western partners. This is the Minsk 2.0 option, which both warring parties have called “suicidal.” Unlike other options, it is equally bad for both sides, thus providing a balance of sorts, a kind of esthetic symmetry. So why does Minsk exist? To serve foreign interests. (See our commentaries Minsk 2.0: Time Is on the Side of Novorossiya and Minsk 2.0 Chess Match: Has Zakharchenko Outplayed Kiev?.)

Scenario IV: Freezing the conflict … which favors Russia. And it does favor Russia, but not for the reasons Horbulin thinks. It favors Putin’s anti-Donbass agenda, which is to quell outrage over the adoption of Crimea, to cool EU hostility, to dump the fiasco into the mine tailings of history so Putin can resume his appeasement of the West, while allowing him to wash his hands of responsibility. But it does not favor the cultural and ancestral Russians of Donbass. It doesn’t even favor the oligarchs!

Scenario V: Limited war and continued negotiations. This is Minsk n++ ad infinitum. The Minsk 2.0 Agreements will expire, however, if the Package of Measures is not fulfilled within a year. Meanwhile, DPR Prime Minister Alexander Zakharchenko and Contact Group envoy Denis Pushilin have both declared there will be no Minsk 3.0. This variant is therefore doomed.

Scenario II: Give up Donbass and break off relations. I have left this option until last, precisely because it’s the best. And being an optimist, I believe it’s also the most likely. I’m encouraged Horbulin has suggested it. If Ukraine gave up Donbass now, the world would forget in a week or two. Ukraine’s oligarchs would quickly adjust. They’re good at adjusting; that’s why they’re rich. The US would hardly notice, as electoral euphoria trumps European affairs. Corporations would welcome a settlement so they could write up new contracts. And poor beleaguered Putin would be off the hook. Clearly this is the simplest, the most humane, and the happiest outcome for everyone …

Everyone perhaps except Angela Merkel, whose “Order of Europe” would be shattered. 😀


Quemado Institute Celebrates DPR Prime Minister
Alexander Zakharchenko’s Birthday


Vladislav Deinego and Denis Pushilin

Vladislav Deinego and Denis Pushilin

DPR and LPR will not accord with the
amendments to the Constitution of Ukraine
if Kiev fails to pay due regard to
their suggestions — Pushilin

Purgin: Donbass On the Brink of Renewed Hostilities

Yanukovich BBC Interview




No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Quemado Institute Editorial

Trump’s Israeli-Palestinian Peace Plan: A Sales Pitch for Elitist Rubbish - Commentaries by Marwin Bishara and Karl Pomeroy - January 29, 2020

Quemado Institute Editorial

Deep State Treason, Trump's Foreign Policy and the Warless World - Impeachment Inquiry: A Question of Who Should Be Running the Show - By Sharyl Attkisson of The Hill - Conclusion by Karl Pomeroy - December 8, 2019


Transcript: Assad's Historic Interview on US, Russian, Turkish and Israeli Roles in Syria - Oct 31, 2019 - "As for Trump, he is the best American President, not because his policies are good, but because he is the most transparent president." -- Bashar al-Assad

Quemado Institute Reports

BOLIVIA COUP: U.S. Regime Change Operations Explained - By 21stCenturyWireTV - November 11, 2019

Quemado Institute Reports

Rightful President Evo Morales Forced to Flee Bolivia - Truth about the Bolivian Election - By Anthos Helpa - November 13, 2019

Censorship Page

Assange Lawyers’ Links to US Government and Bill Browder Raises Questions - The network of lawyers in conflicting roles in Browder, Assange and US government cases - By Lucy Komisar - Off-Guardian - November 8, 2019

Quemado Institute Editorial

Trump Works for Peace Despite US-UK Globalist Tyranny - Commentaries by Matthew Ehret and Tim Kirby - Strategic Culture Foundation - May 28, 2019

New Directions

VIDEO:.Greta Thunberg in Stockholm November 2018: The Disarming Case to Act Right Now on Climate Change -

Syria Page

VIDEO: Assad from Idlib frontline: Erdogan is a thief and a slave to the US (Subtitles) - Syriana Analysis - October 22, 2019

Censorship Page

VIDEO - UNREAL: Facebook Encouraged Users To MURDER Conservatives - By Laura Loomer - July 12, 2019

Quemado Institute Editorial

Venezuela in Crisis: Is Maduro the People's Choice? - By Karl Pomeroy - May 10, 2019

Quemado Institute Editorial

UK Deep State, Canadian FM Chrystia Freeland, and New World Order Decay - The Strange Case of Chrystia Freeland and the Failure of the ‘Super Elite’ - by Matthew Ehret - Strategic Culture Foundation - May 16, 2019

Quemado Institute Editorial

Julian Assange Arrest: Why the Global Elite Implements Censorship - Defending Julian Assange; Defending the Truth - By Robert J. Burrowes - Information Clearing House - April 20, 2019

Quemado Institute Editorial

Assange Prosecution: Specter of Doom or Beacon of Hope? Opinions of Caitlin Johnstone and Robert Bridge - The End of Truth . . . Or Is It? - April 24, 2019

Quemado Institute Reports

The Hub of World Evil: The British Deep State - By Harun Yahya - - May 16, 2019

Opinion Page

Liberalism's Hypocrisy: A Case Study of American Senator Bernie Sanders - By Alexander Azadgan - - May 16, 2019

Quemado Institute World

Is 5G Technology a Mass Public Health Experiment? - The IFit Zone - April 28, 2019

Quemado Institute Reports

Do you really want to know who runs the world? - The global elite march in four essential columns - State of the Nation - April 26, 2019

Quemado Institute Opinion

Perennial Persecution of Russia: Gun Activist Maria Butina Sentenced to 18 Months for No Crime Because She’s Russian - State of the Nation - April 28, 2019

News From Novorossiya

Volodimir Zelensky, Ukraine President-elect - Contrasting views from Fort Russ and Essence of Time - April 28, 2019

Quemado institute World

(Click image then scroll) Wireless Industry Confesses: “No Studies Show 5G is Safe” - State of the Nation - April 28, 2019

Quemado Institute Opinion

Jared Kushner, Not Maria Butina, Is America’s Real Foreign Agent - News Front - April 26, 2019

Quemado Institute World

-- (Click then scroll to title) -- 5G APOCALYPSE - THE EXTINCTION EVENT - Full-length Video by Sacha Stone - The most urgent issue facing man today is the imminent onslaught of 5G technology. - March 23, 2019

Quemado Institute Reports

(Click then scroll to title.) Notre Dame Fire an Elitist Plot? - The Back Story You Won’t Even Read in the Alt Media - By Robert Steele - State of the Nation - April 16, 2019

Quemado Institute World

5G Technology Not for Arizona - Open Letter to the Arizona State Government - (Image: Stealth 5G cell tower, Tucson Arizona) - April 14, 2019

News from Novorossiya

Tuesday November 27, 2018 - Breaking News from DONETSK and LUGANSK Today

Quemado Institute Culture

Puccini's Most Beautiful Aria - Adriana Martino sings "Quando men vo", Scala, 1965 - From the 1965 movie production of the opera La Boheme, directed by renowned Italian film-maker Franco Zefirelli, under the musical direction of Herbert Von Karajan.

Quemado Institute Modern Physics

Diffusion Gravity and the Quantum Vacuum: Can Virtual Particles Act as Mediators? - Diffusion Gravity: An Heuristic Approach - by DH Fulton - March 30, 2019

Quemado Journal of Gravitational Physics Official Website Link

Investigations in nonstandard theories of gravity and cosmology.

Quemado Institute Editorial

Yellow Vest Protests: France Rejects New World Order Globalists - People Demand Nationalism, Exit from EU, and the Ousting of Ex-Rothschild Banker Emanual Macron - By Karl Pomeroy - December 14, 2018

News from Novorossiya

EVIDENCE: Kerch Incident Was Planned Provocation – Pretext for US Aid, Martial Law, War in Donbass - 21st Century Wire - November 26, 2018

Quemado Institute – World

(Click then scroll to title.) The Catastrophic Consequences Of Climate Engineering - By Dane Wigington - - January 17, 2019

New Directions

Tune in with Life - Burton Backcountry Snowboarding - VIDEO - This magnificent snowboarding episode takes you to the deep mountains of British Columbia, Switzerland and beyond - January 27, 2019

Quemado Institute Opinion

Must View VIDEOS of California Firestorm Analysis: California Fires and the Fallout of the Purposeful Destruction of a State - State of the Nation - November 27, 2018

News from Novorossiya

Editorial on Donbass Elections, Donetsk Leadership and Quemado Institute Future Coverage / By Karl Pomeroy, Quemado Institute Chief Editor / Quemado Institute / November 4, 2018

Quemado Institute World

We Told You That Once The Establishment Silenced Assange, The Rest Of The Media Would Be Next: We Were Right - By Elizabeth Vos - Disobedient Media - August 17, 2018

New Directions

Peace Park 2014 – Awesome(!) - Snowboarding VIDEO - January 27, 2019 - Individualism+Creativity=Joy

Quemado Institute Report

Quagmire Gets Deeper as Globalists Push for War – Finian Cunningham, James George Jatras, Brian Cloughley - Strategic Culture Foundation - August 13, 2018

Quemado Institute Opinion

Freedom of speech in the United States was finally strangled. Who is next? -By Andrey Afanasyev - - August 17, 2018

Quemado Institute World

Julian Assange in Immense Danger - James Cogan - May 14, 2018 - Ecuador Hints It May Hand Over Assange

News from Novorossiya

"There is every reason to believe Kiev regime behind Zakharchenko’s murder." -- Maria Zakharova on the assassination of Alexander Zakharchenko - TASS - August 31, 2018

Day of Sorrow August 31 2018

Donetsk People’s Republic Prime Minister Alexander Zakharchenko, one of the greatest of world leaders, was assassinated today, August 31, 2018, no doubt by Ukrainian saboteurs. He gave his life willingly for the freedom of his country. Let us know he has not died in vain.

For those who mourn the death of DPR President Alexander Zakharchenko, there is some consolation to be found in the comment section at The Saker.


News from Novorossiya

Ukrainian forces shell DPR with two dozen rounds over past 24 hours – JCCC / Thursday, March 8, 2018

Quemado Institute World

Does S400 Make F35 Obsolete? Full Analysis by Defense Updates - The Lockheed Martin F-35 Lightning II which is a single-seat, single-engine, all-weather stealth multirole fighters is undergoing final testing by the United States.

Quemado Institute Report

Syria Strike Fails: US, Britain, France Bomb Damascus Friday April 13 2018 - By Kennedy Applebaum - Based on as-it-happened on-site reports by Twitter source AJSB

Quemado Institute Modern Physics

Quantum Theory of Gravitation - by Vasily Yanchilin - Posted April 12, 2018 - A fascinating new approach to gravity and cosmology, this film is about The Quantum Theory of Gravitation discovered by Russian scientist Vasily Yanchilin.

Quemado Institute Culture Page

Reinhold Messner - World's Greatest Mountaineer - VIDEO Interview set in the Italian Alps

News from Novorossiya

Donbass News - Full Report - December 24, 2017 - SPECIAL CHRISTMAS EDITION

Quemado Institute Syria Page

US supports Kurds in Syria: Turks react - By Mehmet Ersoy - January 27, 2018 - The Operation Olive Branch in northern Syria started five days ago. Five days ago the Afrin region became a possible hotbed of a full-scale . . . CLICK TO READ MORE>>

News from Novorossiya

Kiev launches over 1,200 shells on DPR territory in 24 hours - JCCC - DONi News - November 26, 2017 - The Ukrainian army launched more than 1,200 shells on the front-line localities of the Donetsk People’s Republic over the past 24 hours . . . Click image for more>>

Quemado Institute Editorial

New Lugansk Leadership Offers Hope For Donbass Unity - Eduard Popov - Introduction - LPR Presidential Transition: The Dark Side and the Light Side - By Kennedy Applebaum - Lugansk after the Coup: Towards a Unified Donbass People's Republic? - By Eduard Popov - Fort Russ - November 26, 2017

Quemado institute Syria Page

Russian special forces repel US-planned attack in Syria, denounce USA and issue a stark warning By The Saker - September 21, 2017

Quemado Institute Opinion

(Click then scroll to title.) VIDEO - CIA Agent Whistleblower Risks All To Expose the Shadow Government - September 7, 2017

Quemado Institute Editorial

Cataclysm of Planetary Decline: Are Insects Facing Extinction? Apocalyptic Forewarning - By Karl Pomeroy - Quemado Institute - August 30, 2017

Quemado Institute Editorial

Afghanistan Escalation: Full Analysis by Quemado Institute - Donald Trump and the War of the Imperial West - By Karl Pomeroy - August 26, 2017

Quemado Institute Editorial

Google Censorship Under Scrutiny – By Claire Connelly - With introduction by Quemado Institute - Revised September 4, 2017

Novorossiya Daily Sun -Official Website Link-

Official Link To Quemado Institute's Dedicated Donbass News Site

Follow Quemado Institute on



Recent Posts

Censorship Looms Over European Union

Quemado Institute editor Karl Pomeroy received a legal threat today in response to a comment he posted on the Russia Insider website about the rise of the R********d banking family. The comment did not mention race, but was of historical content. The threatener accused Karl of “spreading Nazi propaganda,” then repeated the full text of the German Criminal Code Section 130, which outlaws inciting “hatred against a national, racial, religious group or a group defined by their ethnic origins,” which Karl’s comment did not do. A similar law, it was claimed, is now in force in 11 other European countries and carries a penalty of up to five years. The wording of the law is so vague, it could be applied to any criticism of those in power. If a political analyst can accidentally “violate” this totalitarian decree, there is no freedom of speech or press in Europe.

%d bloggers like this: